Blog Comments, Social Bookmarking, Free Directories, Equals SEO Spam
One of the primary tasks of SEO is generating backlinks. To do this right is no easy task for even seasoned experts. Its time-consuming, rigorous, and just plain hard-work. Often, such work is farmed-out to link-grunts who do all the tedious work for you. Over the past several years this work has evolved into such menial tasks as submitting links to thousands of free directories, blog comments, social bookmarking, forum posts, and article syndication. All these can be valid backlink generators, however; when these things are done wrong, they can backfire.
Let’s look at Free Directory submissions first. Seems reasonable to submit your site to free directories and generate some one-way backlinks. But can it really be that easy? If you pay someone $500 to submit your site “manually” to 1000 free directories are there any assurances that this method is effective? Even worse, are you sure that there is no negative impact for doing it? Even if you found a grunt willing to do it for $100, are you sure about this?
The answer is: you cannot be sure about any of it. You have no real idea what all these directories really are. Are they long-term, or temporary? Are the real, or fake? Its a gamble. In the worse case, some directories are bad neighborhoods, or penalized sites of which you have no way of knowing unless you research each one. If they are “bad sites”, you do not want to be associated in anyway. Why risk it? Do you really think search engines are not aware of all the garbage directories out there? This tactic is just throwing money away.
How about Blog Commenting? The idea here is that you can comment on many blogs and include your URL so that when the comment is published it generates a backlink. Sounds nice, but; its a load of crap. First of all, most blogs have “nofollow” comment backlinks, so your link is fairly worthless even if it gets published. Second, most REAL blogs will spam your comment if it is the typical meaningless generic nonsense like,
“I love your posts. This topic needs to be discussed. Thanks for the great blog!” (URL link: www.viagrasuperhugesale.com)
Do you really think blog owners who want to build a solid web blog will allow this nonsense? Third, any blog that is deliberately set up with “do follow” URLs in the comments and advertises to SEO forums that they are a “do follow” blog… are not real blogs. They are non-authoritative and built for SEO purposes only. Also, most of the “services” who do all this blog commenting for you do it on ALL worthless blogs. Don’t you think Google and the others notice phony blogs and phony comments? Do you think they are stupid? Do you really think you can fool them?
As for social bookmarking and article syndication, the same principle applies. Namely, creating a bunch of fake posts on a forum, making phony profiles on social sites, or syndicating the same exact article on a bunch of crappy article sites DOES NOTHING POSITIVE, and may even be negative.
Am I saying that these things at their core are not solid SEO tactics and techniques? No, actually they are. The problem I am pointing out is in the execution. It is human nature to want the fast-track, the easy way; and such phony methods serve that end. But, they pollute the Internet with SEO spam. There may have been a time when this sort of “backlink blitz” worked well, but that time is gone. All of these tactics are good only if they are done correctly. What is the correct way? Ahh… that’s for me to know, and you to find out.
Comments
Comment from anchor directory
Time March 24, 2011 at 1:03 pm
yes of course directory submission is a great source for getting back links and traffic also
Comment from spirulina
Time April 15, 2011 at 2:29 pm
Really I don’t understand why commenting is taken as spam sometimes. If I want to be called spirulina it is my choice. If comments with website are allowed – why messages signed by my keyword are being taken as a spam? When I comment this post and I called me as Robin then it is ok but if I use my keyword then is not allowed? I am not a spammer but if I coment somebody’s post I also help, isn’t that true? Something for something. I think it’s a nice deal.
Comment from Keenan Fitzgerald
Time April 15, 2011 at 2:56 pm
Comments that are either nonsense or promote an off topic website are not welcomed by legitimate blogs. If one is trying to create a clean authoritative website then such comments are detrimental to that goal not a “nice deal”. Additionally, comments are supposed to be responses that contribute to the discussion. Blog spam are junk comments that don’t contribute to anything except a vain attempt to get free links back to the commenter website. Finally, a site owner has the right to allow certain comments and delete others by whatever reasons they choose. The only beneficial comments are real, natural responses to the the topic. The visitor has the right to leave a comment, and the owner has the right to remove the comment. Simple really. There is no implied “deal” going on.
Comment from Nishant Kumar
Time December 28, 2010 at 5:55 am
I am greatly thankfull to you for this nice post. It was very interesting and helped me with my own project I am doing. eAnswerNetwork (I) Pvt.Ltd. is a Company which organize the Search Engine Optimization and Web designing.